Pizza lovers in Tampa are spoiled for choice. From authentic Italian pizzerias to innovative local gems, the city’s pizza scene reflects its diverse culinary heritage and vibrant food culture. Whether you’re craving a slice of thin, foldable New York-style pizza or the indulgent layers of a Chicago deep-dish, Tampa has it all. In this guide, we’ll explore the top pizzerias, must-try pizza styles, and hidden gems for every type of pizza enthusiast.
A Slice of Tampa’s Pizza History
Tampa’s love affair with pizza began in the mid-20th century, as Italian-American families brought traditional recipes to the Sunshine State. Over time, these authentic styles blended with Tampa’s unique culinary flair, resulting in a variety of options that cater to both purists and adventurers. Today, pizzerias in Tampa range from family-run establishments to trendy spots with modern twists on classic recipes.
New York-Style Pizza in Tampa
New York-style pizza is all about simplicity and flavor. Its signature thin crust, foldable slices, and robust tomato sauce have made it a favorite across the United States—and Tampa is no exception.
Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza
📍 Address: 203 E Twiggs St, Tampa, FL 33602
📞 Phone: (813) 390-6833
📆 Holidays: Monday, Tuesday
🌐 Website: Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza
Located in the heart of downtown Tampa, Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza is a local institution. Their secret? Dough made with water imported from New York, which they claim is the key to replicating that iconic taste.
- Ambiance: Casual and bustling, with a steady flow of downtown workers, tourists, and pizza aficionados.
- Menu Highlights:
- Classic Cheese Slice ($3.75): A no-frills favorite with a crispy yet chewy crust.
- Grandma’s Sicilian Pizza ($22 for a large): A square, thick-crust pie topped with a blend of mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza: A modern twist that’s incredibly popular with locals.
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free crusts available for whole pies.
- Good to Know: Limited seating, so it’s best for a quick lunch or takeout.
Due Amici Pizza & Pasta
📍 Address: 1724 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
📞 Phone: (813) 248-3832
📆 Holidays: Monday
🌐 Website: Due Amici Pizza & Pasta
Situated in historic Ybor City, Due Amici captures the essence of a New York pizza parlor while offering a touch of Tampa’s local charm. Its late-night hours make it a favorite for night owls and partygoers.
- Ambiance: Cozy and vibrant, with a mix of locals and tourists soaking up Ybor’s lively atmosphere.
- Menu Highlights:
- Meat Lover’s Pizza ($17.99 for a medium): A carnivore’s dream with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.
- Veggie Pizza ($16.99 for a medium): A colorful mix of fresh peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives.
- Garlic Knots: Soft, garlicky, and the perfect side dish.
- Dietary Options: Vegan cheese available upon request.
- Good to Know: They deliver late into the night, perfect for satisfying post-event hunger pangs.
Westshore Pizza
📍 Address: Multiple locations across Tampa, Visit Website and Check the Nearest Location.
📞 Phone: Check the Website for the nearest Location Number of you.
🌐 Facebook: Westshore Pizza Company Facebook
🌐 Website: Westshore Pizza
With its extensive menu and multiple locations, Westshore Pizza offers convenience without sacrificing quality. Their New York-style pizza is a consistent crowd-pleaser.
- Ambiance: Family-friendly and casual, with plenty of seating for groups.
- Menu Highlights:
- Philly Cheesesteak Pizza ($17 for a medium): A local twist combining Tampa’s love for comfort food with New York-style pizza.
- Extra Large Pepperoni Pizza ($22): A favorite for gatherings and celebrations.
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free crusts are available for medium-sized pizzas.
- Good to Know: Known for fast delivery and friendly service.
Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria
📍 Address: 514 N Franklin St, Tampa, FL 33602
📞 Phone: (813) 868-4440
🌐 Website: Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria
📅 Opening Hours:
- Friday & Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria is Tampa’s first traditional Neapolitan pizzeria, offering authentic wood-fired pizzas made with the finest ingredients imported directly from Italy. Established in 2009, Bavaro’s brings the taste of Naples to Tampa with their dedication to the art of Neapolitan pizza making.
Ambiance:
Cozy and welcoming, with a charming Italian-inspired interior. Perfect for casual dining or a special meal out with family and friends.
Menu Highlights:
- Margherita Pizza ($16): A classic Neapolitan favorite made with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
- Diavola Pizza ($18): A spicy delight with soppressata, mozzarella, and Calabrian chilis.
- Pasta Carbonara ($19): Rich and creamy, made with pancetta, egg yolk, and pecorino Romano.
- Tiramisu ($8): A delightful way to end your meal.
Dietary Options:Vegetarian options are available, and gluten-free crusts can be requested for pizzas.
Good to Know:
- Bavaro’s uses hand-crafted, wood-fired brick ovens for all their pizzas, ensuring an authentic Neapolitan experience.
- They offer an extensive wine list and craft beer selection to complement your meal.
- Great for dine-in, takeout, or catering services.
Fabrica Pizza
📍 Address: 142 S Meridian Ave, Tampa, FL 33602
📞 Phone: (813) 605-0764
🌐 Facebook : Fabrica Pizza Facebook Page
🌐 Website : Fabrica Pizza
📅 Opening Hours:
- TUE – SAT: 11:30AM – 9:00PM
- Sunday: 1:00PM – 9:00PM
Fabrica Pizza brings the charm of an Italian trattoria to Tampa’s Channelside district. Their wood-fired oven and commitment to high-quality ingredients make their pizzas stand out.
- Ambiance: Modern and inviting, with a casual vibe perfect for lunch or dinner.
- Menu Highlights:
- Margherita Pizza ($11): A classic choice featuring San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
- Diavola Pizza ($13): A spicy option with soppressata, chili oil, and fresh mozzarella.
- Nutella Pizza ($8): A sweet treat perfect for dessert.
- Dietary Options: Vegan mozzarella and gluten-free crusts are available for all pizzas.
- Good to Know: Ideal for takeout or a quick bite before exploring Tampa’s waterfront.
Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline
📍 Address: 1319 S Howard Ave, Tampa, FL 33606
📞 Phone: (813) 251-0220
🌐 Website: Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures.
Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline has been serving the Tampa community since 1985, offering a variety of specialty pizzas and pastas. Known for their house-made red sauce and fresh ingredients, they provide both gluten-free options and a vibrant dining setting with indoor and outdoor seating.
Ambiance: Vibrant setting with both indoor and outdoor seating, perfect for family gatherings and casual dining.
Menu Highlights:
- Deep-Dish Pizza: For those who enjoy a hearty, thick-crust pizza loaded with toppings.
- Breakfast Pizzas: Unique offerings that are perfect for brunch or a hearty start to your day.
- House-Made Red Sauce: A subtly sweet sauce that adds a delicious dimension to their pizzas.
Dietary Options: Gluten-free options available.
Good to Know: Sally O’Neal’s also offers a variety of pastas and is known for their delicious breadsticks. They have been a staple in the South Tampa community since 1985, providing a family-friendly atmosphere.
Pane Rustica
📍 Address: 3225 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629
📞 Phone: (813) 902-8828
🌐 Website: Pane Rustica
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Closed on Sundays
Pane Rustica is a stylish bakery and café that also serves exceptional Neapolitan-style pizzas. Their attention to detail and use of premium ingredients make this a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in Tampa.
Ambiance: Upscale yet relaxed, with an open kitchen that lets you watch the pizza-making process.
Menu Highlights:
- Funghi Pizza ($15): Topped with wild mushrooms, truffle oil, and fontina cheese.
- Margherita DOC ($13): A certified Neapolitan classic with the freshest ingredients.
- Artisan Bread: A side that perfectly complements their pizza offerings.
Dietary Options: Limited, but gluten-free crusts are available on request.
Good to Know:
Great for a date night with a refined atmosphere.
Practical Tips for Enjoying Neapolitan Pizza in Tampa
- Timing is key: Neapolitan pizzas are best enjoyed fresh out of the oven. Many pizzerias offer dine-in seating so you can savor the perfect balance of a crisp yet tender crust.
- Shareable sizes: Most Neapolitan pizzas are personal-sized but can be shared if paired with salads or appetizers.
- Reservations recommended: For popular spots like Pane Rustica, especially on weekends, it’s wise to book a table in advance.
Chicago Deep Dish and Local Specialties
While Chicago-style pizza might not be Tampa’s primary claim to fame, the city offers exceptional options for fans of this rich, hearty style. Additionally, Tampa has developed unique local specialties that reflect the city’s creativity and culinary diversity. From deep-dish indulgence to inventive Tampa-inspired pies, this section covers it all.
Windy City Pizza
📍 Address: 19651 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Tampa, FL 33647
📞 Phone: (813) 388-5844
🌐 Website: Windy City Pizza
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
For an authentic taste of Chicago in Tampa, Windy City Pizza delivers. Known for their buttery, flaky crusts and robust toppings, this pizzeria is a go-to for deep-dish lovers.
Ambiance: Relaxed and family-friendly, with a nostalgic touch of Chicago pride.
Menu Highlights:
- Classic Deep-Dish Pizza ($20 for a medium): Layers of mozzarella, Italian sausage, and chunky tomato sauce.
- Spinach and Mushroom Deep Dish ($21 for a medium): A vegetarian favorite.
- Italian Beef Sandwich: A Chicago staple that complements their pizza offerings.
Dietary Options: Limited gluten-free options; however, thin-crust pizzas are available for lighter alternatives.
Good to Know: Their deep-dish pizzas take time to prepare (45–60 minutes), so plan accordingly or call ahead for takeout.
Paul’s Chicago Pizza
📍 Address: 1500 N McMullen Booth Rd, Clearwater, FL 33759
📞 Phone: (727) 723-9777
🌐 Website: Paul’s Chicago Pizza
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Though located slightly outside Tampa, Paul’s Chicago Pizza is worth the drive for its authentic flavors. This spot channels Chicago tradition with thick, cheesy pies and generous portions.
- Ambiance: Casual and welcoming, with a neighborhood pizzeria vibe.
- Menu Highlights:
- The Works Deep Dish ($24 for a medium): Packed with sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers.
- Thin-Crust BBQ Chicken Pizza ($16): A lighter option with bold flavors.
- Garlic Bread with Cheese: A popular starter to share.
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free crusts available for thin-crust pizzas.
- Good to Know: They also serve Chicago-style hot dogs and Italian beef sandwiches for a complete Windy City experience.
Tampa’s Unique Local Pizza Specialties
Apologies for missing that detail! Here’s the corrected version with the website link included:
Gourmet Pizza Company
📍 Address: 610 S Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33609
📞 Phone: (813) 258-1999
🌐 Website: Gourmet Pizza Company
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Closed on Mondays
Gourmet Pizza Company stands out for its unique, handcrafted pizzas made with high-quality ingredients. They’re also known for catering to dietary preferences with gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian options.
Ambiance: Cozy and welcoming, with a focus on community dining.
Menu Highlights:
- Caribbean Jerk Chicken Pizza ($16): A flavorful combination of jerk chicken, red onions, and cilantro.
- Truffle Mushroom Pizza ($18): Featuring earthy mushrooms and white truffle oil.
- Mediterranean Pizza ($15): Topped with feta, olives, sun-dried tomatoes, and spinach.
Dietary Options: Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese are available for all pizzas.
Good to Know: They also serve creative salads and craft sodas for a refreshing pairing with your pizza.
Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar
📍 Address: 1724 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
📞 Phone: (813) 443-0906
🌐 Website: Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Due Amici is renowned for its New York-style pizzas and classic Italian dishes, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Ambiance: Casual and inviting, perfect for family gatherings and casual outings.
Menu Highlights:
- Pepperoni Pizza ($18): Generous toppings of spicy pepperoni and mozzarella.
- White Pizza ($17): Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil.
- Chicken Alfredo Pasta ($15): Creamy Alfredo sauce with grilled chicken over fettuccine.
Dietary Options: Vegetarian options available; inquire about gluten-free modifications.
Good to Know: They offer delivery and takeout services, making it convenient for a night in.
Tips for Deep Dish and Local Specialty Pizza Lovers
- Plan for a leisurely meal: Deep-dish pizzas often take longer to cook, so these spots are best enjoyed when you have time to relax.
- Pair with local brews: Many of Tampa’s specialty pizza spots, like New World Brewery, offer excellent beer pairings to elevate your meal.
- Share the experience: These hearty pizzas are often big enough to share, making them perfect for group outings.
Late-Night Pizza Options in Tampa
Whether you’re wrapping up a night on the town or need a midnight snack, Tampa offers plenty of late-night pizza spots to satisfy your cravings. These pizzerias are perfect for night owls, partygoers, and anyone in search of a warm, cheesy slice during unconventional hours.
New York, New York Pizza
📍 Address: Multiple locations, including 1512 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
📞 Phone: (813) 248-1845
🌐 Website: New York, New York Pizza
Another Ybor City favorite, New York, New York Pizza stays open until 3 a.m. on weekends. With its wide range of pizzas and quick service, it’s a hotspot for late-night crowds.
- Ambiance: Lively, with a mix of locals and tourists grabbing a slice.
- Menu Highlights:
- Pepperoni Pizza Slice ($3.75): A classic for any hour.
- Chicken Alfredo Pizza ($18 for a medium): Rich and satisfying.
- Wings and Fries Combo: A popular alternative to pizza.
Pizza Box
📍 Address: 923 Central AvenueSt. Petersburg, FL 33705
📞 Tel : 727-623-0444
🌐 Website: Pizza Box
For those near SoHo, Pizza Box is a hidden gem serving wood-fired pizzas late into the night. Their focus on artisanal quality makes them stand out, even at odd hours.
- Ambiance: Quaint and intimate, with a rustic vibe.
- Menu Highlights:
- Truffle Pizza ($15): Earthy and luxurious, with a crispy wood-fired crust.
- Margherita Pizza ($12): A simple yet delicious choice.
- Seasonal Pizzas: Rotating specials that highlight fresh, local ingredients.
Tips for Late-Night Pizza Hunting
- Arrive early on weekends: Many late-night spots get busy after midnight, especially in Ybor City.
- Consider delivery: If you’re staying in, several of these pizzerias partner with delivery apps to bring your pizza to your door.
- Explore the area: Locations like Ybor City and SoHo have a vibrant nightlife scene, making these pizzerias part of a larger experience.
Family-Friendly Pizza Spots
When dining out with kids, finding a pizzeria that caters to families is key. These Tampa spots offer welcoming environments, kid-friendly menus, and plenty of space to keep everyone happy.
Cappy’s Pizzeria
📍 Address: 4910 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33603
📞 Phone: (813) 238-1516
🌐 Facebook: Cappy’s Pizzeria Official Facebook Page
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Closed on Mondays
🌐 Website: Cappy’s Pizzeria
🌐 Facebook: Cappy’s Pizzeria Official Facebook Page
Cappy’s is a Tampa classic known for its retro vibes and laid-back atmosphere. Kids love their colorful booths and the chance to watch pizzas being made.
- Menu Highlights:
- Cheese Pizza ($15 for a large): Always a kid favorite.
- Build-Your-Own Pizza ($12 for a medium): A fun way for kids to choose their toppings.
- Caesar Salad ($8): A fresh side for the adults.
- Good to Know: They offer Chicago deep dish and thin-crust options, so everyone gets their favorite style.
Westshore Pizza
📍 Address: 401 N. Howard Ave.Tampa, FL 33606
📞 Phone: ( 813 )-250-1200
🌐 Website: Westshore Pizza
As previously mentioned, Westshore Pizza’s extensive menu and spacious dining areas make it a great choice for families. They also offer delivery for convenient family nights at home.
- Kid-Friendly Features:
- Affordable kid-sized portions.
- Plenty of parking and high chairs for little ones.
Dietary Options for All Pizza Lovers
Tampa’s pizzerias are increasingly catering to dietary needs, ensuring everyone can enjoy a slice.
- Gluten-Free Options:
- Fabrica Pizza: Offers gluten-free crusts that maintain a Neapolitan-style texture.
- Paul’s Chicago Pizza: A solid choice for gluten-sensitive diners.
- Vegan Options:
- New World Brewery: Vegan cheese and creative plant-based toppings available.
- Due Amici Pizza: Customizable vegan-friendly pizzas on request.
- Vegetarian Options:
- Pane Rustica: Known for their inventive veggie pizzas like Funghi.
- Ella’s Americana Folk Art Café: Unique vegetarian pies like their Eggplant Parm Pizza.
I found This Pizzerias in Tampa
While Tampa has its fair share of popular pizza spots, there are also hidden gems that offer something different from the usual pizza experience. Whether you’re a local or a traveler, exploring these lesser-known pizzerias might lead you to your new favorite slice.
Mamma Mia’s Pizza
📍 Address: 10040 Hudson Avenue, Hudson, FL 34669
📞 Phone: (727) 862-6844
🌐 Website: Mamma Mia’s Pizza
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Mamma Mia’s is a local favorite that serves fantastic traditional pies with a touch of old-school charm.
Ambiance:
Homey and welcoming, like stepping into a classic Italian pizzeria.
Menu Highlights:
- Cheese Pizza ($12 for a large): Simple but delicious, with a perfectly crispy crust.
- Meat Lovers Pizza ($17): A hearty pie with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon.
- Baked Ziti ($10): Another favorite that pairs well with pizza.
Dietary Options:
Gluten-free crusts and vegetarian toppings are available for customization.
Good to Know:
Mamma Mia’s has a great “slice and a soda” deal, making it an affordable choice for lunch or a quick dinner.
Tampa Pizza Company
📍 Address: 777 N. Ashley Drive Suite C, Tampa, FL 33602
📞 Phone: (813) 463-1600
🌐 Website: Tampa Pizza Company
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Tampa Pizza Company is a well-loved spot for handcrafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients.
Ambiance:
Casual and comfortable, perfect for quick bites or relaxed meals.
Menu Highlights:
- Classic Cheese Pizza ($15 for a large): A simple yet satisfying pizza made with their signature dough and tangy tomato sauce.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza ($18): A spicy and bold option with buffalo chicken, blue cheese, and ranch.
- The Ultimate Veggie ($17): Loaded with fresh vegetables and perfect for vegetarians.
- Garlic Knots ($6): Freshly baked and served with marinara sauce.
Dietary Options:
Gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly options are available.
Good to Know:
Known for its generous portion sizes. Visit early during peak hours as it gets busy.
La Cosa Nostra Pizzeria
📍 Address: 409 W Platt St, Tampa, FL 33606
📞 Phone: (813) 259-2233
🌐 Website: La Cosa Nostra Pizzeria
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Located in Tampa’s Hyde Park neighborhood, La Cosa Nostra offers a unique twist on traditional Italian pizza.
Ambiance:
Comfortable with an old-world Italian vibe.
Menu Highlights:
- Margherita Pizza ($13): Simple but loaded with quality ingredients.
- Baked Ziti Pizza ($18): A mashup of pizza and pasta for those who love both.
- Focaccia ($6): A great starter before the pizza arrives.
Dietary Options:
Gluten-free crusts and a variety of vegetarian toppings are available.
Good to Know:
The restaurant’s wine selection pairs beautifully with their pizzas. Don’t miss happy hour specials!
Stoner’s Pizza Joint
📍 Address: 15441 North Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
📞 Phone: (813) 436-0016
🌐 Website: Stoner’s Pizza Joint
🗓️ Weekly Holiday: Open daily; no weekly closures
Stoner’s Pizza Joint is known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious pies.
Ambiance:
Casual and comfortable, perfect for dining in or taking it to-go.
Menu Highlights:
- Classic Cheese Pizza: A timeless favorite with a perfect blend of cheese and sauce.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza: Tender chicken and tangy BBQ sauce.
- Veggie Supreme: Loaded with fresh vegetables for a hearty and healthy option.
- Garlic Knots: Freshly baked and served with marinara sauce.
Dietary Options:
Vegan cheese and gluten-free options are available.
Good to Know:
They offer online ordering and have a strong social media presence with updates and special offers.
Where to Go for the Best Pizza in Tampa
Tampa’s pizza scene offers something for everyone, whether you’re in the mood for traditional Neapolitan, indulgent deep-dish, or inventive local creations. From family-friendly pizzerias to hidden gems and late-night spots, this city’s diverse selection of pizza will satisfy every craving.
Recap of Must-Try Spots
- For Neapolitan lovers: Check out Fabrica Pizza and Pizza 1905 for a taste of Italy.
- If you’re craving Chicago-style deep dish: Windy City Pizza and Paul’s Chicago Pizza are your go-to destinations.
- For unique local flavors: Ella’s Americana Folk Art Café and New World Brewery offer delicious, unconventional options.
- Late-night pizza? Head to Due Amici Pizza & Pasta or New York, New York Pizza for a midnight slice.
- Family-friendly options: Cappy’s Pizzeria and Westshore Pizza cater to both kids and adults alike.
Whether you’re a Tampa local or just visiting, there’s no shortage of pizza places to explore. Many of these pizzerias offer gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice.
Related Resources
For those traveling to Tampa, check out our guide on flights from Tampa to New York.
Looking for a unique experience? Don’t miss our tips on how to rent a tiki boat in Tampa.
We hope this guide helps you make the most of your pizza journey in Tampa!
